miércoles, 25 de febrero de 2009

Quantifying the President's Speech

Doug Mills/The New York Times



Our friends at speechwars.com have put together a really fun tool to help you mine their database of the full text of all State of the Union Addresses (even though this wasn't technically such an address) as well as inaugurals. It

20 comentarios:

  1. For those of you who wondered who the _first_ president to say "ferret" was, it was Eisenhower in '55.

    ResponderEliminar
  2. Here's a feminist perspective... George Washington mentioned "women" only one time in 1795. Then, no president mentioned "women" until Lincoln in 1861. Things have improved a bit since then.

    - Lisa

    ResponderEliminar
  3. I'd love the speechwars folks to diversify and produce a web site that compares the politicians speeches with the eventual results of their ideas/ plans. I'd like it across all politicians from all parties, including the executive branch.

    Talks is cheap and action is expensive. Once action is taken there always will be the ever present unintended consequences, major or minor.

    ResponderEliminar
  4. re: #2

    Things certainly have changed. Did you check to see if Geo. Washington might have mentioned "ladies" instead?

    ResponderEliminar
  5. re: #4

    Here are some other feminist firsts:

    "mother" was first used by John Quincy Adams, 1826
    "mothers" James Buchanan, 1859
    "wife" Abraham Lincoln, 1862
    "wives" Ulysses Grant, 1871
    "girls" Rutherford B. Hayes, 1878
    "woman" Chester A. Arthur, 1881
    "lady" Chester A. Arthur, 1884
    "ladies" Grover Cleveland in 1888
    "daughters" Grover Cleveland in 1893
    "daughter" William Jefferson Clinton, 1999

    Interesting how the roles of women in the public eye evolved.

    - Lisa

    ResponderEliminar
  6. Did anyone but me notice that First Lady Michele Obama wore a very plain dress and did not wear a necklace? I would have thought Tiffany, Fassbinder or Harry Winston would have loaned her ANYTHING.

    ResponderEliminar
  7. we're supposedly on the verge of a freaking crisis here we cant have the prez's wifey wearing glitter and bling

    ResponderEliminar
  8. Concerning the word"crisis", none of the other Presidents had to face 8 years of crisis background esp. the one which included engaged troops and wars in foreign countries and not just the supplying of war materials to other countries.. great depression back in the 30's had a possible cure. supply war related stuff to other countries, but it didn't face the aspect of actually engaging soldiers to this extent...

    ResponderEliminar
  9. Obama has never given a State of the Union address.

    ResponderEliminar
  10. Wait a minute... last night was State of the Union? I thought it was a session in which the President addressed Congress!

    I'm so confused, on account of being Canadian, I guess.. ;-)

    ResponderEliminar
  11. en.wikipedia.org/wiki/State_of_the_union

    "Sometimes, especially in recent years, newly inaugurated presidents have delivered speeches to joint sessions of Congress only weeks into their respective terms, but these are not officially considered State of the Union addresses. The address is most frequently used to outline the president's legislative proposals for the upcoming year."

    ...

    "Since 1989, in recognition that the responsibility of reporting the State of the Union formally belongs to the president who held office during the past year, newly inaugurated Presidents have not officially called their first speech before Congress a "State of the Union" message."

    Still, these first-year-of-first-term speeches are still considered by the public as informal State of the Union addresses, since if it was a president were entering his or her second term, they would be giving an official state of the union address that night.

    - Lisa

    ResponderEliminar
  12. I find it interesting (but not surprising) that the score is:

    love - 89
    war - 2,757

    also

    accountability - 29
    responsibility - 463

    and not to be left off

    defend - 120
    attack - 214

    ResponderEliminar
  13. re: #3
    Talk *is* cheap. (So are transcripts, I imagine.) What you'd suggest would take way way way more manpower than some text banks and a few lines of code.

    ResponderEliminar
  14. I think it's indicative of our concrete-bound culture that we're somehow analyzing what words he used and not what he actually said...

    ResponderEliminar
  15. "Love" being an intangible emotion that doesn't say anything concrete about government and "war" being something we have to face that is universally considered to be negative, I think I feel safer with a president talking about "war." Realism > demagogue.

    Also, using the word more doesn't mean they're considered better. I'm sure the average doctor uses the word "cancer" a lot more than the word "generocity." Or the average pacifist says "war" a lot more than most people >_>

    ResponderEliminar
  16. Vin - you mean that FDR (or, if you count new presidents, Truman) didn't have a decade of depression in his past? George Washington didn't have years of a tumultuous government that even led to the creation of a whole new system? The years leading into and during the civil war wasn't a crisis?

    Methinks you ought to go back and check that out. Your Bush Derrangement Syndrom has made you forget basic history.

    ResponderEliminar
  17. you missed the qualifying of the President's speech- How many times did he use the expressions "we," "our" "us." seems like the op.ed. page has been using these expressions alot lately- Hmmmmmmmmm!

    ResponderEliminar
  18. Do you people seriously think reading what some speechwriter has pinned down really counts for anything? C'mon... There must be better things you can look out for in the president. Words in speeches???

    ResponderEliminar
  19. Bill Clinton was the first and only president to use "yo" during a presidential speech. Respect.

    ResponderEliminar